1928-S Standing Liberty Quarter PCGS AU58, we grade 59.95...

Choice in every way, and quite honestly, I don't understand how an experienced grader could call this anything lower than 58+. To be perfectly blunt, you can find coins like this in 63 holders all day long. Do I think it's a 63? Much like the 1919 in ANACS 58FH I just listed...no. But I fully expected it to grade that way! In the old days, I'd simply try it again. That strategy does not work in the current grading climate (hint to PCGS...if you think being "tough" on coins encourages re-submissions, I think you're wrong).