1916-D Barber Quarter PCGS AU58

Another coin that CAC and I have not seen eye-to-eye on.  This one is a head-scratcher.  I bought it at ANA, and showed it to a couple dealers who's opinions I trust.  Both wanted to buy it and offered real money.  I declined, thinking I would get a Gold Sticker on it myself.  You see the result of that effort.  Interesting, since the coin is nicer than most of these I see in MS62 and even 63 holders...and with less wear too!  And, the eye appeal is really sweet.  OK...maybe I'm wrong...and the other dealers too...but I don't think so.